If you are still having problems viewing this message, please click here for additional help.


January 16, 2015
We Aren't Charlie
The Decline of Satire and Culture
John Stonestreet
Radical Islam, Secularism and Christianity
By John Stonestreet
Archaeological Evidence
By Eric Metaxas
The Ministry of Officer Ramos
By Eric Metaxas
Midwives, Second-Class
By Eric Metaxas

The massacre in Paris has me wondering: are cultural decadence or Islamic extremism our only two choices?

On Sunday, January 11, upwards of one million people, including many heads of state, marched in Paris in protest of the terrorist attacks on the offices of the magazine Charlie Hebdo and a Jewish supermarket.

The slogan “Je Suis Charlie”—“I am Charlie”—has become a kind of badge of honor. It has come to signify a commitment to a kind of liberal and tolerant social order over and against the forces of censorship and Islamic extremism.

But is it the kind of thing a Christian can or should say?

Now, let me get the obvious out of the way: What happened in Paris was despicable. No matter how offensive the magazine’s cartoons might have been, nothing justifies murder.

And let’s be clear about one thing: The magazine’s treatment of Christianity has been far more obscene and disrespectful than its treatment of Islam. Yet, as Rod Dreher wrote at the American Conservative, “It would not occur to me that anyone should lay a hand on the ‘Charlie Hebdo artists or editors who produced that [anti-Christian] filth.” I talked about this yesterday on BreakPoint, and how it shows an important distinction between Christianity and radical Islam.

I fully agree with Dreher’s words that “I do not want to live in a political order in which cretins like [the cartoonists of ‘Charlie Hebdo’] have to fear for their safety, much less jail.”

But that is a long way from saying “I am Charlie.”

What’s lost in all this “I am Charlie” rhetoric is that, in a truly healthy culture, our choices wouldn’t be limited to Islamic extremism or an anything-goes nihilistic libertinism promoted by that magazine.

Such a culture would understand the difference between true satire and offense for its own sake. As Carl Trueman wrote in First Things recently, satire worthy of the name “challenges human pretension and presumption and reminds us of our limits and our fallibility . . . Whether it is Isaiah the prophet poking fun at those who worship wood and stone . . . [or]Jonathan Swift pillorying the Church in ‘Gulliver’s Travels’ . . . the satirist confronts the powerful and calls them to account.”

Most of all, “the best satire is that which fits into a larger moral vision.”  When it targets Christianity, or any other religion for that matter, it does so by pointing out “the absurdities, corruptions, and failings of Christian institutions in a way that should provoke thoughtful reflection.”

While there are still examples of this kind of satire out there today, much of what passes as satire, whether it’s Charlie Hebdo, or to a lesser extent, the cartoon South Park here in the U.S., is offense for its own sake. Its goal is not to provoke thoughtful reflection or reflection of any kind. Its goal is to test the limits of what can be said—just to be more “edgy”, vile, and disgusting than the next guy.

As I said yesterday on BreakPoint, that’s in keeping with our current cultural trajectory in which personal freedom, especially in the sexual sphere, is the only thing regarded as sacred.

Because of that, as Dreher put it, “the decadence represented by ‘Charlie Hebdo’ is probably a greater threat to Western civilization than anything the Islamists can dream up.”

Taking it one step further, he added, “except in the cases of Islamic fundamentalists, I would much rather have observant Muslims as my neighbors and my children’s playmates than someone with ‘Charlie Hebdo’s’ worldview.”

While the kind of Islamists who perpetrated the attacks in Paris have never built a thriving society, Dreher notes, “at the same time, the society the West has built and is building without God or any kind of sacred values other than the Self cannot be said to be thriving either.”

It’s evident in many places, not the least of which is our increasing inability to produce satire worthy of the name. And that’s why I say, we are not Charlie.

Before I leave you today, Eric Metaxas and I would like to invite you to tell us what you think about BreakPoint. Come to BreakPoint.org and take our listener survey. When you do, you’ll be entered to win a copy of Eric’s new book “Miracles.” Thanks so much.

More on This Topic
Gather more information on today's Daily BreakPoint by visiting www.breakpoint.org.

Visit BreakPoint.org

Next Steps:

Do you agree with Rod Dreher? Is decadence a greater threat to Western society than radical Islam? Give us your feedback. And while you're posting a comment, take our BreakPoint survey. When you do, you’ll be entered to win a free copy of Miracles by Eric Metaxas.


Defending the Culture of Death?
Rod Dreher | The American Conservative | January 12, 2015

A Colson Center Program

Forward This Email




'If I Stand' and the Longing for Home

The Onion vs. the Anti-Theists

Hate Speech Laws Backfire

Are Christian Films Coming of Age?

Visit Our Blog Page

Christian Worldview Journal VIEWPOINT

from the Colson Center

The Chuck Colson Center for Christian Worldview is continuing with its TV series on the NRB Network (National Religious Broadcasters) airing
Monday night 8:30 PM EST
NRB Listings here  

We encourage you to share this newsletter on Facebook, Twitter and other social media sites. Help us spread the word and please share your opinions.

Visit the BreakPoint website to read related articles and to hear the latest radio broadcasts.

View Today's Commentary on the BreakPoint website.

This is a rush transcript. This copy may not be in final form and may be updated.

BreakPoint is a program of the Chuck Colson Center for Christian Worldview
Copyright 2015 The Chuck Colson Center for Christian Worldview. All Right Reserved.

BreakPoint/Chuck Colson Center for Christian Worldview
44180 Riverside Parkway | Lansdowne | VA | 20176

Subscribe to BreakPoint

You are receiving this message as a subscriber to BreakPoint's daily newsletter.

Update your BreakPoint/Colson Center subscriber preferences.

Unsubscribe from all BreakPoint/Colson Center emails.